In this letter Mr Osborne addresses the article titled “Reincarnation” by Rene Guenon, and requests a clarification of some information regarding the topic. In his opinion neither the article “Reincarnation” nor the article “The Mountain Path” really explained this topic sufficiently. The response of the Maharshi in this topic was disappointing in Mr Osborne’s opinion because he brushed aside questions regarding the existence of knowledge as an essential part of human beings. According to Mr Osborne “It is rather disturbing to find a spiritual writer discussing the subject (of reincarnation) without even referring to the deeper question of whether there is an ego to reincarnate.”